Recurrent Respiratory Papillomatosis
NEWSLETTER
Vol. 16 No. 1 An
RRP Foundation Publication
2007-08 Winter
P.O Box 6643, Lawrenceville, NJ 08648-0643
www.rrpf.org
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
In
Memory
This issue of the RRP Newsletter is dedicated to Aundrea Humphrey (age 14) and Tracy Byerly (age 35). Sadly, both Aundrea and Tracy recently passed away from complications associated with their RRP.
Aundrea was originally diagnosed with RRP at 4 months of age and first diagnosed with pulmonary papillomas at age 7. She endured about 300 surgeries in 14 years with RRP.
Tracy was diagnosed with papilloma in the lungs in 1992. She underwent 133 surgeries and 2 lung resections as she battled this devastating disease.
Our thoughts and prayers are with their families.
Contents
q
Opening Comments - p1
q
RRPF Organization
Information - p2
q
RRPF Publication and
Subscription Policy - p2
q
RRP Network News - p3
q
RRP Listserve Highlights - p3
q
RRP Patient Survey Stats - p3
q
Patient Support–
p3
q
Fundraising– p4
q
RRP Meetings –
p4-7
RRP Focus Session 2007– p4-6
RRP Task Force Meetings Summaries– p6-7
q
Adjunct Therapy Update– p7-8
I3C/DIM
– p7-8
q
Science & Research Activities – p8-10
RFP
for promising RRP research – p8
RRP Research Dilemma – p8-10
Support/Subscriber Info – p11
From the RRPF Board and Officers
The RRP Foundation has been supporting and networking the RRP community for more than a decade and wants to continue to be responsive to the needs of the RRP community. In this regard we would appreciate any comments you may have regarding the RRPF. The best way to let us know what you are thinking is by email to one of the members of the RRPF Board, i.e., Chris Neuberger, Maura Burke Weiner, Susan Woo or Bill Stern, (see addresses listed in the section on “Organizational Information”.)
We continue to seek additional help in preparing, editing and coordinating the publication of the RRP Newsletter. In particular, we are asking for a volunteer to take on the lead role of coordinating and publishing future issues. If you are interested in assisting in any way, please contact Bill Stern (bills@rrpf.org).
We hope you find this newsletter issue to be interesting and
helpful. Our best wishes for health and happiness during this holiday season
and in the New Year.
We are most grateful to all those individuals, medical
professionals and corporations who have supported the RRPF.
Although it is impossible to publish the names of all who contribute, we
extend our sincere thanks to everyone who has supported our efforts. Future
donations from individuals, professionals or from the business community will
be very much appreciated.
Tax-deductible contributions may be made to:
RRP Foundation
P.O.
Box 6643
Lawrenceville,
NJ 08648-0643
Do you donate to the United Way through your employer? You can select a "Donor Choice"
option, which would allow you to direct a donation to the RRPF as the 501 (c) (3) of your choice. Since the RRP
Foundation is a 501(c) (3) foundation, you may specify the RRP Foundation
directly by writing in the name and address of the foundation as follows' RRP
Foundation, P. O. Box 6643, Lawrenceville, NJ 08648. If you should need to add
our Fed. ID number, it is 521798693. Thank you for your support.
Donations accepted online from the RRPF home page
(www.rrpf.org)
or go directly to http://www.rrpf.org/donate.htm
Special Acknowledgments
We would like to thank Medtronic Inc. and Medtronic Foundation for their continuing support of the RRP Foundation.
To physicians and nurses: Please distribute copies of this newsletter to your RRP patients. Please register with the RRPF or provide updated information about your RRP patient population by completing the online Practitioner Questionnaire at: http://rrpf.org/practitionersurvey.html.
RRPF Officers, Directors & Advisors
Marlene Stern
President
P.O. Box 6643
Lawrenceville, NJ 08648-0643
(609) 530-1443
marlenelin@aol.com
Bill Stern
Director and V. President
P.O. Box 6643
Lawrenceville, NJ 08648-0643
(609) 530-1443
bills@rrpf.org
Henry Woo, Esq.
Secretary
Medtronic International Inc.
Suite 1602 16/F., Manulife Plaza
The Lee Gardens, 33 Hysan Ave.
Causeway Bay,
Hong Kong
henry.woo@medtronic.com
Chris Neuberger
Director and Treasurer
12505 Cobblestone Pkwy.
Oklahoma City, OK 73142
(405) 603-8850
cneuberger@eti1.com
Maura Burke Weiner
Director
4900 Fieldwood Court
Fairfax, VA 22030
(703) 691-1922
Susan Woo
Director
Hanking Court, Flat 9B
43 Cloudview Rd.
Northpoint
Hong Kong, SAR
(852) 2812 7379
susanleewoo@hotmail.com
Scientific Advisory Committee
Thomas R. Broker, PhD, University of Alabama at Birmingham Schools of Medicine & Dentistry
Linda Miller, RN, MSN, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia
Clark Rosen, MD, University of Pittsburgh Voice Center
Robert J. Ruben, MD, Albert Einstein College of Medicine
Keerti V. Shah, MD, DrPH, Johns Hopkins University School of Hygiene and Public Health
Bettie M. Steinberg, PhD, Long Island Jewish Medical Center
Haskins K. Kashima, MD, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine [Emeritus]
Voice Specialist/Advisor
Julie Bowne, M.S., CCC-SLP
RRP Newsletter Editors
Chris Neuberger
Jennifer Woo
Other RRP Newsletter Contributors
Randy Sparkman
Marlene Stern
Bill Stern
RRP Reference Service Editor
David Wunrow
RRPF Fundraising Coordinator
Ed Weiner (703) 691-1922
eweiner@weinerandassociates.com
RRPF Corresponding Secretary
Christine-Hartman Davis
RRPF Patient Support Assistance
Jennifer Woo
Geni Mesi
Lindsay Stern
RRPF Publication and Subscription Policy
The RRPF produces two publications, the RRP Newsletter and the RRP medical reference service. The RRP Newsletter focuses mainly on the human and clinical aspects of recurrent respiratory papillomatosis and in this regard targets a broad readership, including patients/families, attending physicians/nurses, as well as researchers and the general public seeking to stay in touch with RRP from a clinical perspective. The RRP medical reference service serves those in the community seeking a more comprehensive understanding of this disease. Please help us by supporting these publications and other RRP services including patient outreach, support, advocacy and research.
Subscription Policy and Suggested Minimum Annual Donations:
RRP Newsletter
Professional/Corporate
- $25
Individual - $15
RRP Newsletter plus
Medical Reference Service
Professional/Corporate
- $40
Individual - $25
[Note: Issues
of the RRP Newsletter and Medical
Reference Service are available on the
website.]
Our international support network has grown to over 850 respiratory papilloma families. Patients range in age from about 2 to 92 years. Domestically, patients are located in 48 states plus the District of Columbia. Outside the U.S. there are currently 0ver 70 patients from over 30 countries.
Our thanks to all who have taken the time in the past to fill out the RRPF Patient/Therapy Survey. There is now a comprehensive RRP patient survey available online at http://www.rrpf.org/rrpf/survey. So even if you have already completed a survey, help us to learn more about this disease by taking a little time to complete the new survey. Please make sure to alert us of changed addresses by checking the “new address” box. There is also a box which we ask you to check if you do or do not want your name and address information to be included in the RRPF Patient Directory. We are requesting the information contained in this survey be made available for RRP research. In this regard there is a place in the beginning of the survey to grant permission.
As our support network has grown, we have become more dependent on the patient questionnaires to maintain our mailing list and keep our database of RRP patient information up to date. If you are providing updated information, you need only identify yourself, and answer only those questions where you have new information to provide. For the online survey, just make sure you specify the patient’s first and last names and their year of birth.
Doctors and nurses treating
RRP patients, please take a few minutes to fill out the online practitioner
survey form.
You can find the online “patient survey” and “practitioner survey” respectively on the “patient” and “practitioner” page links from the RRPF home page (www.rrpf.org).
We ask that patients and practitioners update their survey at least once a year.
……………………………………………………………………
RRPF Listserve
Update
by Randy Sparkman
The RRPF
"listserve" continues as a valuable resource for the RRP community.
As of December, 2007, the electronic mailing list has over 500 subscribers that
include RRP patients, families, caregivers, researchers and healthcare
professionals.
Over the past
year there are have been many threads about diagnosis, treatment methods and
risk trade-offs. Most importantly, the listserve is a community of care. It is
a place where those of us with long-term RRP and the newly-diagnosed can share
experiences and enjoy the support of others who understand the RRP experience.
The RRPF has
sponsored an electronic mailing list since its inception. The list was hosted
on Yahoo Groups in 1999. Yahoo's search function is included within the site.
The increased number of subscribers along with the multi-year archive of
threads now provides an extensive history of experience that makes the list
even more useful to the community.
On average, there
are now about one hundred posts per month. The posts may be received into your
electronic mail inbox one at a time or can be received as a daily digest of all
posts received that day. As with all forms of Internet communication, users
should be careful with personal information. Posts to the RRPF website are not
linked by search engines such as Google. Access to the mailing list requires
registration as a Yahoo user and approval of the mailing list
"moderator", currently the RRPF director. Despite these safeguards,
authorized members have the ability to copy and redistribute mailing list
information. So, again, be thoughtful as you post medical and personal
information.
To subscribe to
the list simply access: http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/rrpf/ from your
Internet browser. Those who
need technical assistance with the RRPF listserve can send an e-mail to
jubrising@gmail.com for one-on-one assistance.
Please complete or update
the comprehensive RRP patient survey available online at: http://www.rrpf.org/rrpf/survey
NOTE: If you have
received Gardasil vaccinations whether by standard protocol or in any other
manner, please indicate this on your survey via the “other” entry category.
Very preliminary statistics may be viewed at:
http://www.rrpf.org/rrpf/survey/update/admin/
user = “rrpf”
password = “Foundation” (case sensitive)
(Caution: These are
“raw” stats and in some cases may not make sense.)
[For support of new RRP research initiatives, please
see section on “Science and Research Activities”]
Support for RRP patient related travel expenses:
The RRPF has dedicated a limited amount of funds to provide indirect support of some travel expenses to obtain treatment for RRP families truly in need. We are doing this by providing small grants to two charity travel organizations, i.e., Miracle Flights for Kids and Angel Flights. If you would like more information please contact:
Geni Mesi
(801) 358-9351
e-mail: mesifam@hotmail.com
Please come to the Sixth
Annual
RRP Foundation Team USA
HOCKEY NIGHT
At the VERIZON Center
Washington, D.C.
Saturday, February
2, 2007
Questions? Contact Ed and Maura Weiner
maura.weiner@jurymatters.com
100% of proceeds from this fundraising event go to the
RRP Foundation. Everyone wins!
RRP Focus Session 2007
Highlights
DVD of the
Focus Session will be available early in 2008!
The RRP Focus Session is an event that is often convened in
conjunction with the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery
(AAO) annual convention. The following is a summary of the proceedings of the
2007 meeting, held on September 14, 2007, in Washington DC.
There were about 45-55 attendees including RRP patients,
parents, RRP doctors and researchers. Highlights of this year’s meeting
included updates from the RRP Foundation, the RRP Task Force, and the RRP ISA
Center; updates on HPV vaccines; the heterologous effects of the MMR vaccine;
Celebrex therapy for RRP; an in-office laser treatment protocol for RRP; a PDL
procedure for treating RRP; and a therapeutic vaccine for canine
papillomavirus. The presentations were informative and well received, and the
meeting and the dinner that followed provided fertile ground for discussion and
interaction among members of the RRP community, many of whom had traveled from
across the country to attend.
The following summaries are presented as highlights only.
Details are provided in the PowerPoint on the web at:
http://www.rrpf.org/meetings/RRP_focus_2007/RRP_Focus2007Program.htm
We strongly encourage you to refer to the Powerpoints for more
specific information on the topics outlined below.
I. RRP Foundation Priorities and
Perspectives (Bill Stern)
Opening remarks from Bill Stern
RRP Priorities, Awareness, Epidemiology, Research Support
Ongoing and past supported projects
Major patient/family concerns
Diagnosis issues, coping with RRP, treatments (surgical and
adjunct), voice (preservation, restoration/improvement), mortality (pulmonary
involvement, malignancy), disease transmission
RRPF List-serve Overview - forum for exchange of information,
ideas, opinions and emotions related to RRP
Currently ~500 members consisting of patients, parents,
practitioners, researchers
Collecting RRP Patient Data: provide informational support for
RRP families and practitioners, improve understanding o RRP epidemiology,
availability of database for RRP research studies, Web-based survey linked to
MySQL, coordinate with RRP ISA Center
Pulmonary RRP: greatest risk of mortality from RRP, approximately
6% of RRP patients, remains virtually untreatable, propose to establish
referral centers to coordinate experimental treatments and clinical research
II. International RRP ISA Center
Update (Michael Green)
Who We Are, What We Do
Policy Board - up to 9 individuals
Scientific Advisory Panel
Research efforts
Gardasil -
VLP-based
vaccine, near-total immunity against HPV 6,11,16,18
Merck
used reproductive tract data to generalize regarding therapeutic efficacy elsewhere
Dr. Ian Frazer - currently using VLP treatment RRP vaccine in
Brisbane, China, similar to Gardasil but without Al adjuvant
AIDS Data: AIDS patients get all kinds of opportunistic HPV
infections except RRP à assumption that reproductive data map to respiratory
system is “highly questionable”
Want to educate more broadly on 20/20, Oprah, 60 Minutes about
HPV being not just a female disorder, there is RRP involved too, it is not just
cervical cancer and genital warts
III. RRP Task Force Update (Craig Derkay, MD)
Meets twice a year, in conjunction with AAO and COSM
No further funding from CDC to continue registry
Formulated statement on public health infection concerns for
children with RRP
Tackling statement on HPV typing
Post-licensing suggestions for RRP vaccine trials
vaccinate cohort of children currently in remission
begin surveillance study of new onset RRP
attempt therapeutic trial
establish anti HPV 6 and 11 antibody levels in cohort of
actively treated RRP patients to determine who might benefit from therapeutic
administration of vaccine
Overview of Gerein et al (2006) - patients with RRP are able to
have healthy children regardless of stage of disease. Pregnancy has a negative
impact on disease course, worse with HPV 11.
Toxicity issues with Cidofovir: potent carcinogen in rats (Annals
2005)
Should be routinely presented as a treatment option in
moderately to severely afflicted RRP patients, viable option in pt’s whose
disease severity is resulting in a need for frequent surgery/worsening airway
compromise/impaired communication
Role for HPV testing
Clearly,
in the pediatric airway, HPV 11 = high risk
Review of several ongoing and recently published studies
(Maloney, Buchinsky, Gerein, Reidy, Wiatrak)
HPV sub typing: Linear array kit, Digene HPV Test, AMPLICOR HPV
test
Celebrex study - supported by Task Force
IV. RRP Genetics
(Farrel Buchinsky, MD)
RRP genetics study enrollment tripled since LA 2005, discovered
transmission disequilibrium in 2 candidate genes
Cause of RRP: HPV 6 and 11, necessary but not sufficient
Many exposed, only a few get the disease
Genetic susceptibility: higher prevalence in relations, HLA
DRB1 0301 and DQB 0201 disproportionately present in RRP, rabbit papillomas
data, HIV/AIDS, malaria, mortality by infectious disease in adoptees more
associated with biologic parents than seen for cardiovascular and cancer
Overview of data collection process
Regulatory process impediment to most would-be collaborators
Which gene or genes - candidate gene or genomic scan approach
Candidates: MHC, innate immunity, known cell biology
interactions, other diseases
Transmission disequilibrium test
V. Pulse Dye Laser for treating
RRP (Matt Brigger, MD)
585 nm PDL in children with RRP, all children will be treated,
no placebo
Safety of PDL has been established
Sites: Boston, San Diego, Birmingham, Cincinnati
The problem: mucosal disruption, scarring potential à
do not disrupt opposing mucosal surfaces
Basic CO2 laser physics: 10,600 nm in a continuous beam,
primarily absorbed by H2O, heated to steam, mucosal disruption
1980’s: Parrish and Anderson develop 585 nm PDL based on
selective photothermolysis, destroys vessels within the lesion, destroying
epithelium
Vascular core: prime target for selective photothermolysis
Destruction of papillomas vascular supply results in involution
with mucosal preservation, allowing more complete debulking, potentially better
voice outcomes
Initial, pediatric and adult data presented
Hartnick
2007 - no episodes of vocal scarring or web formation, trend toward increased intervals
Method: general anesthesia, microlaryngeal suspension, debulk
exophytic lesions as needed, use fiber through long cannula or suction
Cleaner ablation of papillomas
Where to go from here: feasibility and safety shown, objective
outcomes are lacking - does a more complete excision result in less procedures?
Are voice outcomes truly better?
Randomized controlled trial with clear objective outcomes
Multi-center efforts needed
Objectives: determine if PDL can increase time interval,
improved voice outcomes
PDL represents potential advantage by allowing more complete debridement; no objective outcomes; need more data to determine role in routine practice t